Letter to Americans & Response

Photo R. Meshar

I came across this post on Zero Hedge a while back. Then I noticed an eye-brow raising response in the comments section. The post entitled “Dear Fellow American” represents a fairly common, American-centered view of our current national economic and political situation. Here’s the original post,  also shown below and the comment follows.

Warning – The commenter to “Dear Fellow American” articulated another view of our situation (follows the post below), that will be very difficult for some to read, much less face. Still, the commenter, who is British, voices some hard truths that many in other countries around the world believe about Americans, our current situation and the U.S. in general.

Dear Fellow American,

I am writing this letter to you not as a liberal, not as a conservative; not as a lefty, not as a righty; not as a Democrat, not as a Republican, not as a Tea Party populist; not as a Christian, not as a Buddist, not as a Moslem, not as an atheist; not as a socialist, a communist and certainly not as a bailout capitalist.

I am writing to you as just another ordinary American.

I’m your next door neighbor, I’m the guy standing next to you at the check out counter, I sit next to you on the bus, I sit next to you at worship, I’m in the next lane over on the freeway, we see each other at work,  I’m right behind you at the cinema and three rows over at the ball game, our kids go to school together. We stare blankly at each other each and every day, but we rarely if ever exchange a word.

Today, I have something important I would like to say to you.

In these twilit days of August, as we watch the so called “power elite” luxuriating in their billionaire beach hideaways, at their billionaire birthday parties, political golf outings, fund raisers and PhD cowboy retreats, I keep asking myself one simple question.

I’m pretty sure you are asking yourself the same question as well. That question is written all over the worried faces of millions of struggling Americans trying to live a modest life within their modest means.

It is written on the faces of the unemployed struggling to pay their bills. It is written on the faces of young adults despondent over their prospect of living under the shadow of runaway debts.  It is written on the faces of children living in homeless shelters, it is written on the faces of struggling entrepreneurs who can’t get a loan, it is written on the faces of all of those frustrated working and out of work people who once had a simple American dream.

Everywhere I look, I see the same question.

Unfortunately,  I don’t see any answers.

All I see is self serving corruption, greed, stupidity, short sightedness and outright thievery by the parasites and leeches that would have us look upon them as our grand leaders and  paragons of commerce.

They ask and take, they take and complain, then they give precious little or nothing in return.

They blather endless platitudes about what’s good for them, then pay feeble lip service to what is good for the rest of us.  Their idea of a free market is that of justice and prosperity to the highest bidder.

They are good at one thing and one thing only, preserving their own status quo by exploiting you, me and the rest of us.

They are callous human strip miners and care absolutely nothing about anything but their own fat cat bank accounts, fat cat sports cars, fat cat jets, fat cat hideaways, fat cat trophy wives, fat cat mistresses, fat cat country clubs and gold plated suntans.

The question I want to ask you is this: Why?

Why is it taking so long for you, me and the rest of us to look each other in the eye and finally say what needs to be said?

Those selfish crooked liars and thieves on Wall Street in collaboration with their hired guns and bought politicians in Washington DC have taken over the town. They are down in the Silver Dollar saloon whoring themselves at a big old drunken Wall Street party while the rest of us are quietly cowering in the miserable shadows of Everywhere USA.

Why are we waiting to speak out, to act, to do what is necessary to protect our families, our children, our grand children and our country, yes OUR country, from those Capital Hill bandits, corporate horse thieves and fast buck bankster snake oil artists?

It is time to take back the neighborhood we call USA. It is time to haul the thieves and swindlers responsible for the mother of all economic clusterfucks  before the court of public justice.

Let them call us populists.  Whatever.  I’ll gladly wear that badge if that is what it takes to set things right.

I know you are busy so I won’t take more of your time. All I ask is you consider what I have said and how it relates to you, your friends family and  loved ones.

If you agree with what I am saying, but wondering what to do, perhaps one way to start is to take this letter, pass it along to the next person and ask them to do the same.

The sooner we all stand up and openly say enough is finally enough, the better we will all be.
Yours sincerely,

WilliamBanzai7

Now the response – an apt reply to “Dear Fellow American” which articulates the feelings of many around the world.

From Zero-Hedge reply 8-20-11 – 13:03 by YHC-FTSE

I spent some time re-reading your efforts, and as laudable as your sentiments are, I fear it is too little too late even if by some miracle the vast majority of your continent share the same feelings – which they do not.

I have tried in vain to summon up some sympathy and compassion for your fellow Americans who find themselves in the present predicament, but every time I do, the faces of babies, children, women, and men your fellow Americans have exploited, raped, poisoned, bombed, knived, and shot around the world during my lifetime surface along with the spurious reasons spoken by a million American lips why they all had to die, each time it happened. I think about the millions of people bombed in Vietnam, Laos, and Cambodia, the 300,000 stillborn babies deformed beyond recognition by Agent Orange, the hundreds of thousands raped by US troops around the world, the legacy of another generation of children deformed and dying from depleted uranium in Iraq, and wars upon wars fought directly or by proxy by those who govern the USA. In my lifetime alone, the picture is staggering.

If America’s Downfall or more aptly, Der Untergang, means I don’t have to hear another Rand-worshipping, paranoid, materialistic, murderous, thieving, delusional, lying fat-American-fuck expound jingoistically on his “Greatest Nation in the World”, then I can only wish it will happen tomorrow. If Der Untergang means justice for the downtrodden by removing American support for despots on their land, the removal of military garrisons of the pretend-Roman-empire on every corner of the globe, and a chance for individuals and nations to finally control their own destinies, then I say bring it on, no matter what the cost to me.

If Der Untergang means the end of the pernicious Ponzi cycle based on debt slavery as saleable asset, and creating wealth out of bullshit with fancy sounding words like, “fractional reserve”, “deposit insurance” and a million acronyms, then I say, yes please. If it sends the whole industry of leeches who make nothing tangible, create nothing useful, and merely suck all the youthful, useful talent into the abyss of a money making gambling machine, and sends them all into oblivion, the human race would be much better off.

I am sure there are those whose hearts are in the right place. The real life versions of Grizzly Adams, The Waltons, or even Earl Hickey in America who despair as much as everyone else in the world at what America has become: A haven for zionists and other fundamentalists who base their lives on causing as much misery to others as they can, and spreading their Malthusian philosophy all the while as an excuse to get rich on the misfortune of others. If you are that person in despair, then you have my sympathies. Otherwise, it is time for Americans to reap what they have sown so widely with their greed. None of you gave a shit when NGOs pleaded that the USD dilution as a reserve currency will cause widespread starvation in the 3rd world because millions will be priced out of staple foods. Virtually none of you gave a shit when you were told about gross abuses and exploitation practiced by US corporations. It’s only now when it affects YOU that I hear the whining. Remember: in a democracy, you have none to blame but yourselves. The World will be a much better place without the kind of people America breeds and nurtures.

What do you think? Are we willing to face the hard reality of how we are viewed by many around the world?

You may also like Demanding Social Justice, Inequality Hurts the Rich Too and How Much is Enough?

Stories About Fighting Back

Shine light in the darkness. People are becoming empowered to fight back.

Check out the Guardian’s Series, “Fighting Back” – “A series of investigative documentaries about poverty, commissioned and editorially controlled by Guardian Films, in association with Christian Aid”

 

You may also like Farmers Pushed Off Their Land By Investors, Life of Water; Water of Life and What Can You and I Do?


Wealth Distribution Thought Problem

Photo A. Meshar

How should wealth be distributed? In an article entitled Wealth Inequality, Dan Ariely at Technology Review.com asked Americans this very question.

“Perform the following thought experiment. Remove yourself for a moment from your present socioeconomic circumstances and imagine that you are to be replaced randomly into society at any class level.

Now, before you know your particular place in society you are told that it is within your powers to redistribute the wealth of that society in any way that you choose.  What distribution would you choose? This famous thought experiment is the basis of political philosopher John Rawls, as outlined in his highly influential 1971 work, “A Theory Of Justice,” in which he argues that the lowest class should be made as well off as possible.” (Bold was added)

What distribution would you choose? Click here to see how those surveyed responded. What do Americans believe is the current wealth distribution in the U.S.? –

“. . . participants rather badly estimated the current state of wealth disparity! Furthermore, they offered an ideal wealth distribution (under a “veil of ignorance”) that was even more different (and more equal) relative to the current state of affairs.

What this tells me is that Americans don’t understand the extent of disparity in the US, and that they (we) desire a more equitable society.”

These results tell me two additional things. First, for all the rhetoric we read in the media against socialism, it turns out that Americans are a lot more socialistic than they would like to believe because they believe in a more equitable society.

Americans frequently forget that we are VERY socialistic about some things. We want just one water supplier or sewer system, for example. The same is true for electricity, natural gas and other utilities. In fact it makes sense here.

Second, Americans believe in a social safety net – what an equitable society requires.

The reality is that all healthy societies, in the past and today, provide a base income or social safety net for everyone before others are allowed to retain great wealth.

Once basic human needs are assured then wealth disparity becomes less problematic because the social problems caused by wealth disparity – shrinking middle class, unemployment, crime, drug abuse, poor health, lack of skills – are minimized or eliminated.

You may also like How Extreme Inequality Destroys the Economy, Surprise! Health Insurance Improves Lives and Does Everyone Have a Voice?

Is There Reincarnation?

Photo A. Meshar

My students were discussing reincarnation. This topic came up in yoga study as well.

Much has been written on reincarnation. I put together some considerations below. You may find them useful. Caveat: What I write is from a theological stance (as I am a theologian) so the starting point is different for me (as a believer) than for non-believers.

Also, as an educator I believe that religious traditions have much to teach us. We can appropriate many things, even though we may not choose to use everything. However, the things we choose to appropriate or believe must further justice in the world, not diminish it. Otherwise that belief is, by definition, immoral.

So with these parameters in mind, here we go.

On Reincarnation: From time to time I am asked about my belief in reincarnation or whether or not we experience more than one life. Some religious and philosophical traditions believe in reincarnation – Hindu, Yoga and some Buddhist traditions for example. We can’t completely eliminate reincarnation as a possibility since we can’t really know for sure.

In the Judeo-Christian scriptures God is relational with the world and with God’s people. As theologian John Haught might say, it is a story that is unfinished. It isn’t perfect but with promise in order to draw us into a future. God is the lure. God promises creation a banquet of relationality moving from chaos to complexity & coherence. In this story time is linear – meaning it doesn’t repeat. Our experience of time is the basis for God’s story, this drama. Time has a beginning and a goal, purpose or end.

Logic & Reason. In the Catholic tradition science and religion are not opposed to one another. They ask different questions. Science asks, “How did the world and what we observe in it come to be?” Theology asks, “Why is anything here at all?” Because they ask different questions science and theology can actually support each other. This is why so many Catholics are also scientists, researchers, doctors, astronomers etc. This is why Catholics build universities and hospitals. We believe that because God created the world and called it “good” we are free to respectfully investigate and explore the world. So what does this mean for belief in reincarnation?

Science tells us that space and time are actually one continuum. We experience them separately – but they are one, nevertheless. Knowing this, it would be difficult to accommodate for a belief in reincarnation. Reincarnation says that I, as a person, could exist in multiple lifetimes. Stated another way, I could exist simultaneously in more than one place/time on the space/time continuum. In order for that to happen I would have to be not one consciousness, but many. I’m not sure that could logically happen and still claim that I am a unique person, a unique entity or consciousness with free will.

If we choose to believe that we are not unique persons with our own consciousness and free will, then religious traditions that believe in reincarnation would have to radically overhaul their understanding of personhood, self-understanding and choice in order to be consistent and not contradict their own teachings on the development of the personhood of each individual. If my consciousness isn’t unique to this time/space continuum and simultaneously exists elsewhere, then I’m not solely responsible for my decisions and choices in this local/time.

With this understanding of consciousness or personhood it would be impossible to uphold the rule of law, for example, as it exists around the world today.

Certainly, life experience has something to bring to this issue. The actual experience of reincarnation says that a child suffering horribly from disease or hunger today is simply experiencing the consequences from bad choices in another lifetime. Really? That a young child suffers without having any knowledge of these other decisions, means that the suffering happens without understanding, without hope for growth, without purpose. This won’t move us toward universal compassion but rather to abandonning it. To believe this is to believe that ultimate reality or God is cruel and capricious. This would be a horrible God or reality not worthy of union. This is untenable as an understanding of God or reality.

Conversely, I believe that reality (God) is good and loving at its core. My experience is that reality is intelligent, relational, generative and therefore it must be fundamentally loving – to us and to the entire universe. To believe otherwise one must ask, why continue living?

Further, my own life experience tells me that even I, as a human parent, would not punish my child for something they did long ago and had no memory of. But reincarnation says that God would do exactly this. Am I, a mere human, more compassionate or loving than God?

To attribute suffering to actions from previous lifetimes prevents us from going deeper to learn the true causes of suffering. This is the immoral or unethical result of believing in reincarnation. Suffering from disease, poverty and hunger are not the result of karma. We find new cures for diseases all the time – think of the March of Dimes and their progress curing birth defects.

Poverty and hunger are the result of our inability to distribute food properly to the human family. There is enough for all. Unfortunately we have created an economic system that favors some over others. But if we go deeper, educate ourselves and make changes we can make sure that basic needs (water, clean air, food, education, basic health care) are available to all. This is our task. This is what it means to become truly human. Belief in reincarnation too easily takes us away from this task.

So, to conclude, I can’t totally eliminate reincarnation as a possibility since we can’t really know for sure. But using heart (compassion) and head (reason), I draw different conclusions about the degree of its possibility and probability. Belief in reincarnation requires overcoming the objections described above in order to be an ethical or moral possibility that I could truly embrace.

As always, questions and comments welcome.

You may also like Lunar Eclipse, Only 3.9 Billion Years Left and The Fourth Dimension.

“Age-Friendly” Means Friendly For ALL

Photo R. Meshar

There’s so much we can do – even in our own local communities. Check out all of the innovative ideas in this article with excellent resource links at the end.

Here are just a few good ideas from the article –

It will take some creative steps to make New York and other cities age-friendly enough to help the coming crush of older adults stay active and independent in their own homes.

“It’s about changing the way we think about the way we’re growing old in our community,” said New York Deputy Mayor Linda Gibbs. “The phrase ‘end of life’ does not apply anymore.”

With initiatives such as using otherwise idle school buses to take seniors grocery shopping, the World Health Organization recognizes New York as a leader in this movement.

But it’s not alone.

Atlanta is creating what it calls “lifelong communities.” Philadelphia is testing whether living in a truly walkable community really makes older adults healthier. In Portland, Ore., there’s a push to fit senior concerns such as accessible housing into the city’s new planning and zoning policies.

The key is understanding this (bold emphasis mine):

. . . if you make something age-friendly, that means it is going to be friendly for people of all ages, not just older adults,” said Margaret Neal of Portland State University’s Institute on Aging.

DH and I are actively looking for places to live in retirement that would allow us to use no car, public transportation or only one car. Walking is paramount – to the library, volunteering, faith community, grocery store, restaurants, coffee shops, museums, health care appointments and more. It is healthier, active, you meet more people and it’s easier to stay involved in the community. Check here for a list of most walkable cities in the U.S.

Because we have simplified our lifestyle we don’t need much space for stuff/things (a large kitchen or dining room isn’t necessary, for example). But we do know from our own experience that diversity in people and activities greatly enhances our quality of life.

What do you think? Would you consider adding diversity in people and activities to your life? Would you move to a place where you could easily use public transportation and then actually use it?

You may also like Live a Little, Prairie Walk and Simplify, Simplify, Simplify.